semipr0

Two computers, different IP's, same house, cannot connect to same server

71 posts in this topic

Few days ago I got Arma 2 for my wife so she could play DayZ with me. We played for a whole day with no problems whatsoever. The next day I died in an accidental friendly fire situation, after I died and tried to login to the server, my wife's client suddenly stopped communicating with the server and lost connection, and I was unable to make a full data connection.

Now no matter what we do, if I'm on US 155, and she tries to join, my client stops communicating with the server and I eventually time out, and she cannot log on to the server at all til she retries after I'm off. If I try to log in behind her, she gets dropped from the server in the process. And this happens on any server we try to join together.

We have two seperate IP's, we have seperate CD keys for our Steam installations of Arma 2 CO, and we can both play just fine as long as we're not on the same server.

I've reset our router, updated its firmware, flushed both our DNS caches and the problem continues to persist.

Anyone else seen anything like this and know any solutions?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I want a wife to play DayZ with man. That's wicked. I'm so pissed that you can't play together right now, that's lame. Sorry I can't help, just wanted to help fuel your rage about this. Best of luck pal.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not really raging, just trying to work it out. Had some friends on our Teamspeak end up with the same problem tonight too so they didn't play tonight so our little band of survivors was short 3 people. I eventually logged out cause of a lack of ability to play with my wife and friends.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Have you swapped computers by chance? - I imply that both your player profiles may be on both computers raising a conflict of some sort?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

perhaps use an IP changer? Don't know much about networking and stuff though..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Have you swapped computers by chance? - I imply that both your player profiles may be on both computers raising a conflict of some sort?

We never log into each others Steam accounts. Neither computer has a profile for the other account. I've checked that too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thats not quite applicable as we have seperate IP's assigned, not a single IP.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If I understand, your PC's have different IPs, but they are connected via one router - modem, which has only one IP. That would be the problem.

Edited by Clasius

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

perhaps the other computer can use someone elses wi-fi?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If I understand, your PC's have different IPs, but they are connected via one router - modem, which has only one IP. That would be the problem.

Even then we had no problem connecting to the same server the first day she played with me. It only started happening the next day after I died, now we cannot play on the same server together.

If what you are proposing was the case we'd have had the problem from day one, not on day two.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If I understand, your PC's have different IPs, but they are connected via one router - modem, which has only one IP. That would be the problem.

Correct. Both of your computers will have a seperate private IP address. This private address identifies you on the network and usually starts out as 192.168.0.XX.

Your IP address on the internet is what is know as a public IP address. Your public IP address is assigned by your ISP to your router, which is what the rest of the internet sees. To test simply google "whats my ip address".

:)

A solution would be to connect to a VPN from one computer (which will route all your internet traffic and give you a new public IP address) and run the others internet traffic through the router as per normal.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Even then we had no problem connecting to the same server the first day she played with me. It only started happening the next day after I died, now we cannot play on the same server together.

But it's strange to attribute the problem that you died, and after that you can't connect.

I would try this:

A solution would be to connect to a VPN from one computer (which will route all your internet traffic and give you a new public IP address) and run the others internet traffic through the router as per normal.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Looks like dayZ has no support for identical IP addresses. My only suggestions are to:

A. Connect through a different internet connection(not ideal really)

B. Use a proxy server to connect one computer through before joining the game.

C. Some sort of ip changer which i am not very familiar with.

Niall

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Looks like dayZ has no support for identical IP addresses. My only suggestions are to:

A. Connect through a different internet connection(not ideal really)

B. Use a proxy server to connect one computer through before joining the game.

C. Some sort of ip changer which i am not very familiar with.

Niall

A proxy sever will only reroute traffic on port 80 (HTTP) by default (ie a web proxy) - there are specific proxies for different ports by 99% are for HTTP traffic.

A VPN will cover off point A & C. Instead of rerouting just web traffic (port 80), the VPN will reroute ALL traffic from your computer to its interface.

Have a look at the following article from Microsoft for connecting to a VPN (This guide is for Windows XP however connecting to a VPN from Windows 7 nearly identical):

http://support.microsoft.com/kb/314076

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Looks like dayZ has no support for identical IP addresses. My only suggestions are to:

A. Connect through a different internet connection(not ideal really)

B. Use a proxy server to connect one computer through before joining the game.

C. Some sort of ip changer which i am not very familiar with.

Niall

My brother and I connect through the same router without any problem whatsoever, it's probably one of the internal router / firewall / ?peerblocker? settings.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been pouring through my router settings and there isn't anything different there that wasn't there as of a few days ago.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Our IPv4 addresses are different but our external IP Is the same.

I've forwarded all the relevant Arma II ports in my router. We still cannot connect to the same server, for some reason the servers cannot filter our NAT addressing and realize that we're two different computers attempting to connect to the same server.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The server will never realise that you are two different computers connecting. This is because your internal network is private and unable to be seen by the DayZ server. There is no issue with your router - you are able to get to the server correct? Regardless of if one of you is not able to play or not. That means that the server on the other end is rejecting the connection.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We've been gaming with the same internet connection and home networking set up for years now, we've never had any problems playing together on the same servers for any game other than Arma II/DayZ.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My roommate and I are having the same issue, started happening after we upgraded from patch 94876, but downgrading both the patch and battleeye has yet to fix it. Still trying to find a solution, we've never had any issue of the sort before and have been playing DayZ on the same setup for about a week prior to this cropping up.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My roommate and I are having the same issue, started happening after we upgraded from patch 94876, but downgrading both the patch and battleeye has yet to fix it. Still trying to find a solution, we've never had any issue of the sort before and have been playing DayZ on the same setup for about a week prior to this cropping up.

Well as I said my wife and I were able to play for a day with no issues whatsoever. This was after the 1.7.2.3/94876 update last Friday. She has updated via Six Launcher several times and run into problems getting onto servers running 94876 still so I've gone in and manually removed the latest update and reinstalled the 94876 beta on her computer...but even that and manually reinstalling BattlEye hasn't allowed us to play on the same sever together since Monday 07/16.

And its not just one server that rejects us both connecting, any server we both try to get on together.

If I am already on a server and my wife tries to join it, I get a yellow latency link, then a broken red link and the message that I've stopped communicating with server over and over, once she actually gets to the game lobby, my player name isn't even in the lobby list any more, and when she tries to load in to the game environment, she can't download the full mission file, and has to exit out of the game.

This is definitely very weird because its not like every computer connected to broadband internet has its own individual IP, home networking is extremely common and theres absolutely no reason why we should need two dedicated internet connections or have to pay for a VPN for one computer simply to play this game.

Something about the DayZ server package is denying multiple connections from the same network address and its just started coming up recently.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yea, I created this thread right before seeing yours: http://dayzmod.com/forum/index.php?/topic/37535-wait-for-host-error/

We're in the same exact boat, whoever connects first can play, the second person just gets stuck on "Wait for host", even after leaving, it takes about 5mins before the second person can join the server.

I just tried connecting to the same server as my roommate through my phone, and it worked fine albeit my ping was quite.. spectacular.

I'm going to see about setting up a VPN until this gets resolved, I'll PM you details for it if the lag is not too bad

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've created a bug report here https://dev-heaven.net/issues/37534, if anyone else experiencing the issue wants to weigh in on it, it might help get the problem some attention.

I've also sent a support request to BIS and put up a thread on their trouble shooting forum.

Hopefully an answer to the problem becomes apparent soon.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • By libertine
      Edit: I have now learned that they are in the middle of making some big changes, so if you are a dev, please understand that I realise what I am concerned about you may still be working on. Also, apologies for my comments on Chernogorsk changes, I guess I was wrong about the severity of those changes. I had seen a streamer go through the new Cherno many times and assumed they had taken out the industrial section.........yaaaaaa...no.
      I just started letting DayZ news back into my life after a 3+ year break, hoping to be surprised at all the new stuff, but I started watching some streams. I can't believe what they did to this game (or didn't do). Most importantly I expected to see a couple of new maps, one with a full cityscape like in the movie "I am Legend", (based on Rocket's comments and common fucking sense)) with new places to explore which is something absolutely crtical for the continued enjoyment of peaceful/survivor type players who don't choose to get enjoyment out of PVP'ing/KOSing. I expected a bit of a story or mystery to figure out, like Origins mod team did with Patient Zero on Tavania.
      They did nothing. They basically rearranged some buildings......on a map that people already loved. They changed the trees and grass.....that people already loved. I remember being so happy about DayZ originally partly JUST because people would get to experience the beautiful Chernarus map I had known from Arma 2, a beautiful map that IMO set a presedent in gaming. They felt the need to change it apparently. While some of the changes are a small improvement, there are so many backward steps and all of this development amounts to nothing. We also have far less features than the mod, even less weapon variety. We must kill wolves now. I have no fucking desire to shoot what is basically a wild dog trying to survive. In watching streams, I see people using a tiny stick to poke zombies to death, w....t....f? Is this the type of zombie behavior/fighting you have been planning this whole time? Because I think we might have told you to save yourself (and our wallets) the trouble, not splitting the Dayz community with standalone and instead focusing on further mod dev. You still have only a few head variations and they look like they're relaxed in a fucking cubicle doing office work.
      You guys took out the two best running animations ive ever seen in a game. TWO! Arma 2 had them and you took them out. Why? The new running-with-gun animations looks extremely aggressive, like "I'm going to fuck something up RIGHT NOW!!" aggressive. Looking back at some of the DayZ mod vids, the movement transitions seems so much smoother, like the transition from jogging to crouched-jogging with no speed reduction. I can't double tap the forward key to jump up form crouching and start running quickly. This is just one of a few bits of sophistication from the Mil-Sim aspect of Arma 2 that you REMOVED. We need MORE, not LESS. Its not to say there aren't some improvments with anims and such, but overall after hours of watching streams, we've got a 3 steps forward, 2 steps back game here.
      They also messed Chernogorsk up, the industrial area was the coolest part of Chernarus IMO, its basically gone. The sense of massive industrial scale, dereclict and IMO quite hunting and interesting, they took out, and they did so to make that part of Cherno look exactly like any other town using building we so all over Chernarus. They added an airplane wreck that looks like it belong in a fucking comic book. Planes don't wreck like that, they are way too fragile to hold together. It looks ridiculous.
      So we're they've just rearranged a bunch of stuff, on a map that already worked and looked great!?!? The area east of Chernogorsk, just to the west of Skyrim mountain for example, they developed it with some bigger buildings, but it worked well the way it was. It made sense for that part of town to be a small residential homes with that beautiful hillside backdrop, away from Chernogorsk. Does it REALLY matter that they added bigger buildings? Its...okay....I guess? Does it help improve DayZ? Not for me...
      They took out canned food, one of the most interesting parts of surviving in my opinion and kind of cool and haunting to see one can of food on a shelf, and now food is everywhere, but the process of getting natural food incredibly boring, repetitive and uninteresting, highlighting repetitive, unrealistic animations. Why do the footstep sound effects suck so much (on concrete and a few other surfaces)? (maybe improved now?) In a game, anything that is on the screen full time, or heard over and over and OVER again needs to be 100%.
      One of my biggest gripes is the rarity and variety of cool assault rifles. (not talking about unfair stuff like thermal scopes or high powered-click-your-mouse button-they-die-sniper-rifles) You can take this stuff out and make the game more survival oriented, but you needed to substitute it with something fun. Its just a big loot search fest right now and fighting zombies whos visual detection code barely makes any sense half the time, not adding to and sometimes even breaking immersion. WTF happened at BI Studios this last 4 years? Zombies could be a cool, dynamic element for this game if they had some variation in behavior and the combat with them was realistic, especially the animations.
      One other problem I've noticed watching streams is that loot is so rare that there is no reason not to take EVERYTHING you find,  such that if you are behind someone, looting the same buildings, you may get nothing for hours, surely there is a better way?

      Also, in the original DayZ, everything was a prized possession. Now I can pull an effective melee weapon out of any tree, and it doesn't even look believable (skinny unnatrually straight branch). I can find food in any old apple tree. I thought we wanted Man Vs Guns, not Man Vs. Wild. Don't even get me started about nighttime, holy shit, I could never play that because people WILL USE GAMMA adjustments to find you and you will run and loot for hours only to be shot by some kid who has never pondered the results of his actions. Its a game, there will be kids. By all means, make it dusk, beautiful and haunting. Simulate night, make it feel like night, just don't let a gamma adjustment from the monitor or video card settings give an advantage. Plus, we sleep at night.......yes, we humans sleep...at night...9 our of 10 dentists agree.
      Also, why the unnatural head bounce/bob when moving forward while jogging? It feels cartoony. We evolved to see the world fairly smoothly when moving, same problem with the side-to-side movement when running. Battlefield, starting with 2142 I think has done it the best, they just give a very small hint of the movements your making, truer to real life. Can we reign that in a little bit? Look at Chronicles of Riddick Butcher Bay as a good, although too exaggerated IMO, example.
      --------------------
      One thought occurred to me, that the civil war in Ukraine that is sadly happening is what is effecting development and if that is the case know that I don't intend for this to make you feel bad and to just be taken as some constructive criticism.
    • By Plaster422
      What can i say?

    • By nl
      0.59 Stable. Another bug (imo) that I hope is resolved soon. I mean I can imagine with a lot of gear I would sprain or break an ankle falling from a 40 centimeter height, but dead...Ah well, I was ready to say goodbye to this character anyway in anticipation of 0.60.