Not at all, I didn't even notice your avatar because I haven't see the movie yet. Fiction not being welcome? I love fiction and of course it's relevant. To be more specific I'm referring to when people say things such as "This is definitively how people would act in a post apocalyptic world, read "Insert Post Apocalyptic Book or Movie Here". And yes, "The Road" is often filling that space. That said, I find it humorous not because I disagree. But because there is such ample historical/factual material to confirm this that it shouldn't even be necessary to cull from fiction. Many books and movies cover these scenarios in that fashion correctly assuming this to be a very plausible way people would handle such events. Here's an example from this forum that brought this to mind: It's much worse in places like reddit...Hope this clears things up as the last thing in my mind was attacking you and the chosen example was purely coincidence.