I do believe there should be a melee option if you have a knife or axe, this game is centered around realism. Now let's look at the pros and cons that would come along with this. Cons -You already don't want to be near zombies due to the obvious reasons...health loss, bleeding, broken bones, alerting more zombies, etc. -Health is rare enough as it is. Why would you want to put yourself in harms way if you don't have to? Pros -Using a melee weapon brings that true survival realism effect to the game. -Allows you take out a zombie without alerting more, again stressing the survival realism feel of the game. -Gives you some sort of 'out' if you don't have, are very low or trying to conserve ammo. Especially if patches are trying to implement starting with no guns. -The possibility of using stealth kills if you sneak up behind unsuspecting players, make it personal :D Ways to make it work -Have the axe and knife degrade over time, so you aren't encouraged to just run around with an axe or knife slashing away. -You can only carry one knife and axe at a time. This would prevent people from throwing every axe/knife they find in their bag and 'hoarding' weapons to counter the degrading durability. I feel this would be a huge benefit to the game and really stress that realistic survival feel. I'm not looking for swords, wrenches, etc. to be added to the game, I feel the axe and knife are more than enough. If they're implemented with degrading durability, again it deturs you from hacking and slashing and will prevent the game from turning into L4D. Again, being near zombies now is a bad idea, pretty sure you wouldn't want to go melee only and take on all the disadvantages listed above with being in swing range of a zombie.